In case you were wondering, yes, I was part of that laughed at group of people that went to go see New Moon this weekend. Having read all the books during Hurricane Ike, I felt obliged to go see the movie. Besides, watching Taylor Lautner shirtless is a good reason in its self to go and see it.
As much as I liked the books, the movies seemed almost superficial. I believe that the world was attracted to the books, not necessarily for the characters, but for what they represented, true love. Chris Weitz, the director of New Moon, tried to capture this unconditional love between Isabella and Edward, however on screen it felt lifeless and fake. I think that the idea of true love is what the world is in love with, but with it come disappointment and reservation to all who were expecting it feel it in the movie. True love isn't something that even the greatest actors can capture, if such a thing even exists. Seeing the attempt on screen was unconvincing and distracting.
Moreover, it seemed as if the director was trying to incorporate every scene from the book into the movie. This left me wondering where the conversations between the characters went.
Overall, I think the movies offers something for every audience. There is action, drama, romance, and comedy. Did I mention that Taylor Lautner is in it?